Catholic Digest | The magazine for Catholic living
2008-2009 Living With Christ Sunday Missal
Subscribe Now!
Renew Subscription
Give CD as a Gift
Store
Customer Service
 
Free ENewsletter
>>   Learn More
Quick Links
Bendict Visits America
>> In this issue
>> Election 08!
>> Web exclusives
>> July extras
>> Love your neighbor
>> Readers' Forum
  >>   E-mail a letter to the editor
  >>   Support our troops!
  >>   Help U.S. prisons
  >>   Free downloads, games & more
  >>   Parish finder
  >>   Quick Catholic facts
  >>   Good links
About Us
  >>   About Catholic Digest
  >>   Meet the staff
  >>   In the press
  >>   Writers' guidelines
  >>   To advertise
  >>   Bayard, Inc.
Web exclusives
Article Options:   Printer Friendly  |   Send to a Friend  |   Single Page  |   Readers' Forum  |   Comment

Should our family watch The Golden Compass?*

Catholic Digest offers a framework for making the right decision for your family about this controversial movie

* With new material not available in the print edition

A mysterious, truth-telling compass, shape-changing creatures, ferocious, armored bears racing across snow-covered landscapes, and a scrappy 11-year-old named Lyra Belacqua as the heroine — all that and more are promised in The Golden Compass, a film scheduled for release this December and based on the first volume in Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials, a Carnegie award-winning series for young adults. But there’s more to these books than a well-told adventure story. Here’s the scoop on this immensely praised but controversial trilogy.

What’s the series about, and why is it so popular?

His Dark Materials is an adventure trilogy by British author Philip Pullman (see sidebar for where to find plot summaries). The first volume, known under two titles — The Golden Compass and Northern Lights — was published in 1995. The popularity of the books is partly owed to the excellent writing, complex characters, compelling story, and sophisticated themes. The books raise complex questions about love, life, faith, good and evil, choice versus fate, serving self versus serving others, and more.

Why might the series be anti-Catholic?

The Christian Church featured in the world of the novels — a parallel world to our own — is portrayed as a powerful group of misguided, sin-obsessed individuals bent on oppressing truth, knowledge, and “every good feeling.” The group is often referred to as “the Magisterium.” In this world, the Authority — the God of Christianity, and also a representative of authority in the general sense — is a tyrannical liar who only pretends to have created the universe and who, by the time the trilogy’s ultimate battle is waged, is a pitifully frail old man who is relieved that someone has come along to put an end to his existence.

The character Mary Malone, a former nun introduced in the second book of the trilogy, sums up what would appear to be the author’s view: “The Christian religion is a very powerful and convincing mistake, that’s all.”

Is the author anti-God?

Given the views expressed through the series, and Pullman’s outspoken atheism, one might expect the answer to be an unequivocal “yes.” “I’m trying to undermine the basis of Christian belief,” Pullman told The Washington Post in 2001, and in 2003 he told the Sydney Morning Herald: “My books are about killing God.” In the 2007 interview with Beliefnet, however, he discusses how although the action of killing a (false) god appears in the books, the books are about saving the divine (which in the books appears not in the Authority, but in “Dust,” or consciousness, which the Church of the books aims to destroy).


Page:
1   2   3  

St. Judes